The 7 Best Aftershaves to Soothe & Regenerate Your Skin

Daniel Bishop
Written by
Last update:

Do you want to know if aftershaves are really safe for your skin?

Do you want to know what the best aftershave is for sensitive skin?

In this in-depth guide, we take a comprehensive look at aftershaves to find the best aftershave for sensitive skin.

Aftershaves are essential for every man. However, not all aftershaves are created equal.

Below are reviews of the 7 best aftershaves on the market right now.

An aftershave is an essential part of the grooming process for most men. Many aftershaves are easily available over the counter in drugstores, or pharmacies. Popular brands of aftershave are most often associated with strongly masculine scents and old fashioned brush bottles. However, with a little effort, you will find out that there are some subtle and elegant aftershaves in recent decades too.

In the market, you will find an impressive number of different kinds of aftershaves. The right application aftershave for your skin can soothe and regenerate your skin.

To help you find the best aftershave for your skin, we put together this comprehensive guide.

Without further ado, let’s talk about the 7 best aftershaves for sensitive skin.

Paco Rabanne 1 Million After Shave BalmBest OverallPaco Rabanne 1 Million After Shave Balm
Proraso After Shave LotionBudget PickProraso After Shave Lotion
Bay Rum Aftershave SplashUpgrade PickBay Rum Aftershave Splash

1. Paco Rabanne 1 Million After Shave Balm

Our rating: 9 / 10

Paco Rabanne 1 Million After Shave Balm

Check Price on Amazon


  • If you’re looking for a high-end aftershave this is the one for you
  • All Natural ingredients that work to soothe your skin
  • The moisturizing properties of this aftershave will help make healing your cuts and nicks much easier
  • One of the best and most effective cooling aftershaves currently in the market.
  • Developed for men who want to avoid the burn that is typical of aftershaves
  • The 2.5 ounce bottle will be able to last you a long time
  • The bottle is compact and is easy to carry around with you


  • The scent of the aftershave is not for everyone as it is very strong
  • This aftershave is best for people with dry and sensitive skin
  • When used consecutively this aftershave can be quite drying

First and foremost this aftershave will not cause any irritation or burn. It will not burn and is perfect for men with sensitive skin.

It is also an excellent aftershave for men who are prone to breakouts. It comes in a roller ball container. This packaging makes it really easy to apply and helps you avoid using too much.

This aftershave also has properties that will help speed up the healing of minor cuts. It also moisturizes the skin.

Read more about the Paco Rabanne 1 Million After Shave Balm

2. Jack Black Post Shave Cooling Gel

Our rating: 9 / 10

Jack Black Post Shave Cooling Gel

Check Price on Amazon


  • A great pick for sensitive complexions because it is non-drying
  • Can be used as a pre-shave treatment with or without shaving cream
  • The formula not only consists of chamomile, but it has a short list of other notable ingredients


  • A little pricey for only 3.3 ounces
  • The nozzle can make the gel come out in a zig-zag pattern
  • The packaging is inconsistent with some complaints of leaking

The Jack Black Post Shave Cooling Gel has been created to soothe and revitalize your skin. It will calm and provide relief for both irritated and dry skin. The cooling formula will relax your mind and body after a shave.

The formula is created with 90% organic ingredients, containing a chamomile to help accelerate healing and prevent redness.

This product has been dermatologically approved to be non-clogging on the skin and to minimize ingrown hairs. To help prevent irritation and razor burn the Post Shave Cooling Gel is infused with a unique blend of botanical ingredients to instantly relieve irritation and aloe vera.

Read more about the Jack Black Post Shave Cooling Gel

3. Proraso After Shave Lotion

Our rating: 9 / 10

Proraso After Shave Lotion

Check Price on Amazon


  • Affordable
  • Provides an instant cool sensation when applied
  • Long lasting invigorating effect
  • Does not leaving the skin tight and dry after use


  • It is not very effective when applied immediately after shaving and can leave the skin feeling sticky
  • The alcohol content is about 50%, which is quite high

(Pack of 4)

Aftershaves are lotions that are applied to the skin after shaving. They serve a number of purposes: to prevent irritation, to reduce redness, to eradicate skin bacteria, and to refresh and tone the skin.

One of the most prominent after shave lotions is the iconic Proraso After Shave Lotion, which has been in use since 1948. The Italian brand prides itself on being an effective solution to a wide range of skin-related issues, from inflammation to dryness.

Read more about the Proraso After Shave Lotion

4. Baxter of California Men's After Shave Balm

Our rating: 8 / 10

Baxter of California Men's After Shave Balm

Check Price on Amazon


  • Item has a sleek design without the bulky handle
  • Item dissipates quickly
  • It is easily applied to the skin
  • Item can be used for most other parts of the body other than just on your face
  • The item gives the right amount of cooling effect in a nice manner


  • It is not a specialized after shaver
  • It leaves the skin feeling moisturized
  • The product is not the best smelling one that the user can use

Aftershave Balm helps to soothe a freshly shaven face. The Baxters of California aftershave balm formation is not too thin and not too thick. This facilitates the product to be absorbed into the skin from the balm.

The product is very lightweight, which makes it easy for the user to apply the balm. The effectiveness of this product is that it provides solution to rashes that are normally associated with shaving small areas of the body. Also, this is an aloe vera and ingredient aftershave product made with citrus extracts. This is a necessary ingredient in an aftershave replacement.

The product helps to repair the skin when a man shaves by using a razor to shave.

Read more about the Baxter of California Men's After Shave Balm

5. NIVEA Men Maximum Hydration Moisturizing Post Shave Balm

Our rating: 8 / 10

NIVEA Men Maximum Hydration Moisturizing Post Shave Balm

Check Price on Amazon


  • Available at a very affordable price – it’s the cheapest aftershave on this list
  • Delivers the same performance as high-priced aftershaves
  • Provides an instant cooling effect and a soothing sensation on irritated skin after shaving
  • Helps reduce redness and prevent razor burns and rashes
  • The active ingredient glycerin attracts moisture, which prevents skin from drying
  • Provides long term hydration
  • There are no alcohol, artificial colors, or artificial fragrances added
  • Comes in a package of three, which is convenient if you shave on a daily basis

Bottom Line:

All the products on our list deliver the same performance and quality. That is why we’ve included a product from our budget pick category.

If you’re looking to get value for money, the Nivea Men Maximum Hydration Moisturizing Post Shave Balm is the perfect choice. It’s much cheaper than other aftershaves but delivers the same level of performance. So, if you’re low on budget, then this is the product you should give a try.

Read more about the NIVEA Men Maximum Hydration Moisturizing Post Shave Balm

6. Bay Rum Aftershave Splash

Our rating: 8 / 10

Bay Rum Aftershave Splash

Check Price on Amazon


  • It has a soothing combination of essential oils which includes Bay Oils and Bay Buchu Leaves
  • The product is cruelty-free, vegan and made with all natural ingredients
  • It is easy to apply to your skin and dries quickly
  • It is available in a number of fragrances such as: Bay Rum, Lime, Lavender and West Indian Lime
  • You can easily find it at your local supermarket or pharmacy


  • This aftershave is not ideal for sensitive skin
  • The scent will last only for a short time after application

Aqua Velva Classic Ice Blue After Shave Moisturizer, SPF 6 Clear Gel, 4 fl. oz. Proraso After Shave Balm, 125 ml Alpa Deodorant Stick for Men (Original Postassium Alum)

The Bay Rum aftershave splash has a combination of bay oils and bay buchu leaves. This aftershave will leave your skin feeling smooth and healthy after shaving.

The product is made using cruelty-free, vegan and natural ingredients. The Bay rum is mixed with other essential oils such as clove, Nutmeg, Cinnamon, and Clary Sage. These essential oils have healing and revitalizing effects on the skin.

Read more about the Bay Rum Aftershave Splash

7. Billy Jealousy Shaved Ice After-Shave Balm

Our rating: 8 / 10

Billy Jealousy Shaved Ice After-Shave Balm

Check Price on Amazon


  • It soothes razor burns
  • It’s small packaging makes it great for traveling
  • It’s easy to use; no mess
  • It’s great for sensitive skin


  • Scent can be strongly outspoken
  • It’s more expensive than other aftershaves on the market

What exactly does it do?

This after shave balm cools and heals irritation after a shave, while it provides lasting moisture to help you forget about the dry razor burn sensation like never before.

It goes into greater detail,.

Read more about the Billy Jealousy Shaved Ice After-Shave Balm

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

What is best for skin after shaving?

Chemical aftershaves not only cause your face to burn but also damage your skin. Instead, use a natural aftershave that contains soothing and moisturizing properties. You should select a product which contains ingredients like lemon, aloe, tea tree, almond oil or witch hazel. These ingredients will provide your skin with nutrients so it can regenerate faster.

Aftershaves also have medicinal properties. For instance, aloe can be applied to your skin to expedite the healing process when you have irritation or open cuts.

What is the best post shave balm?

The most prominent purpose of aftershave is to protect the skin from irritation or any infections that may occur as a result of shaving. Some aftershaves address this by including alcohol, which kills bacteria that cause infections.

Post shave balms are different from aftershaves in that they deliver ingredients that not only soothe irritation, but also repair the skin and lock in moisture. Post shave balms also include ingredients that shape the beard better and keep the skin hydrated after shaving to prevent the irritation that shaving causes.

Which is better after shave lotion or balm?

Aftershaves combat ingrown hairs and razor burn, speed up healing, and help prevent acne by combining a toner, astringent, and moisturizer with essential oils. The two main types of aftershaves are lotion and balm.

Lotion is a lighter, more liquid aftershave that’s good for sensitive skin types and those needing a light application. Depending on the brand, it also tends to be good for those with thicker, coarser hair. This is because lotion spreads more easily than balm and therefore will cover your skin evenly.

Balm is thicker and better for working deeply into your pores. This helps to prevent acne and is therefore ideal for those with thicker hair, especially if you have sensitive skin.

You may also want to factor in aroma into the decision too. Most aftershaves contain fragrance, but you may prefer unscented.


Aftershave is considered as one of the essential items for the men if they want to look and feel their best. Whether you are into cool or warm aftershaves, there are three things that you may want to look out for in the aftershaves you buy. These components are the ingredients in it, the aftershave design and the smell of the aftershave.

Our Recommendation

Paco Rabanne 1 Million After Shave BalmBest OverallPaco Rabanne 1 Million After Shave Balm
Proraso After Shave LotionBudget PickProraso After Shave Lotion
Bay Rum Aftershave SplashUpgrade PickBay Rum Aftershave Splash